Forget pumpkin mania, it’s almost time for all things eggnog

Step aside pumpkin spice, the holidays are quickly approaching and it’s time for eggnog to have its moment.

- Advertisement -

While pumpkin permeates the culture every fall — from coffee flavoring to air fresheners — too often eggnog gets relegated to a glass that shows up on tables just a few weeks a year. Creamy, spicy, sweet and often spirited, eggnog is the quintessential holiday beverage. In the spirit of the season, here is everything you need to know about all things eggnog:

* Although eggnog’s origins are rooted in 14th century England, it didn’t really hit its stride until the American colonies got started. In Europe, milk and eggs were expensive in those days, so only the wealthy could afford to drink something that contained both. In the Americas, colonists had their own dairy cattle and chickens, so it was easy and inexpensive to make the drink that became known as eggnog.

* Typical eggnog includes milk and/or cream, spices like nutmeg and vanilla, some form of alcohol, such as rum and raw eggs. In the olden days, homemade eggnog contained alcohol in the hopes that it would kill any bacteria that might be present. Today, we add spirits for enjoyment, confident that all-natural pasteurized eggs.

* Today, you can find eggnog in cartons in the grocery store, in many varieties. If you’re an eggnog lover you’ve probably tried them all … and come to the conclusion that no matter how good store-bought eggnog might be, nothing beats homemade. Fortunately, it’s easy to find eggnog recipes online, and all the ingredients – such as cream, pasteurized eggs, spirits and seasonings – are readily available in your local grocery store.

* Eggnog isn’t just for drinking. It’s a flavorful, festive ingredient in a range of dishes, from breakfast options like to lunch yummies like classic Monte Cristo sandwiches dipped in an eggnog batter and pan-fried. And of course, eggnog has a place of honor in holiday desserts. Incorporating homemade eggnog into recipes is easy, and it brings out the rich, authentic eggnog flavor that makes holiday dishes special.

You can find plenty of eggnog, eggnog-inspired and eggnog infused recipes online at sites like www.safeeggs.com. Here are two eggnog recipes from the safe egg aficionados at Davidson’s:

Caramel Apple Pie Eggnog

Ingredients:

- Advertisement -
Uber Free Rides 728x90

4 Safest Choice pasteurized eggs

1 can (21 ounces) apple pie filling

1 1/2 cup milk

1 teaspoon apple or pumpkin pie spice

whipped cream for garnish

caramel ice cream topping for garnish

cinnamon sticks (optional)

apple wedges (optional)

Directions:

Combine eggs and apple pie filling in a blender. Blend on high speed until very smooth, scraping container as needed. Add milk and apple pie spice. Blend on high speed until smooth.

Pour into glass or mug and top each serving with whipped cream and caramel topping. Sprinkle with additional apple pie spice and garnish with cinnamon stick or apple wedge, if desired.

Classic Eggnog

Makes 20 servings

Ingredients:

12 Safest Choice pasteurized eggs, separated

1 1/2 cups granulated sugar

4 cups heavy cream

2 cups whole milk

2-3 cups dark rum, bourbon or brandy (optional)

2 tablespoon vanilla extract (optional)

ground nutmeg or cinnamon to taste

Directions: Place egg yolks in a large bowl. Beat with electric mixer until combined. Gradually add sugar, beating until mixture is thick and pale yellow. Stir in cream and milk, then rum and vanilla, if desired.

Cover and refrigerate until chilled or as long as overnight. Just before serving, beat room temperature egg whites with electric mixer until soft peaks form. Stir egg yolk mixture, then gently fold in beaten egg whites. Pour eggnog into punch bowl. Sprinkle with nutmeg.

More Stories

chef Basil Jones

Jamaican Chef Basil Jones leads culinary experience on Love & Harmony Cruise

Every morning at 4 a.m.—when most Harmonizers aboard the Love & Harmony Cruise 2026 are fast asleep in their cabins—Jamaican-born executive chef Basil Jones...
Chef Shorne Benjamin

From St. Lucia to Brooklyn: Chef Shorne Benjamin reinvents Caribbean cuisine with Fat Fowl

At the intersection of culture, craft, and entrepreneurship stands Chef Shorne Benjamin, the St. Lucian-born culinary innovator behind Fat Fowl, a Downtown Brooklyn restaurant...

The Cookout brings Caribbean and African flavor to South Beach Wine & Food Festival

The 25th Annual Food Network South Beach Wine & Food Festival reached a cultural high point on Saturday, February 21, 2026, as The Cookout,...
South Beach Wine & Food Festival

Caribbean cuisine takes center stage at South Beach Food & Wine Festival

Las' Lap Link Up: A Celebration of Afro-Caribbean Cuisine will put the best of Caribbean cuisine in the spotlight at Food Network’s South Beach...
cardamom pumpkin pie

How to make cardamom pumpkin pie from scratch at home

Many people celebrate the fall season with pumpkin pie. The only thing that can make the taste of the traditional pie a little better...
Altreisha Foster-Bentho

Jamaica-born chef Dr. Altreisha Foster-Bentho creates cake for Betty Crocker’s 104th birthday

Jamaica-born, Minnesota-based pastry chef Dr. Altreisha Foster-Bentho and her company, Sugarspoon Desserts, were selected by General Mills to craft a one-of-a-kind cake for Betty...
Stush in the Bush

Jamaica’s Stush in the Bush ranked among North America’s 50 best restaurants

Jamaica’s celebrated farm-to-table restaurant Stush in the Bush has earned a coveted spot on the 2025 list of North America’s 50 Best Restaurants, announced...

Hydrating foods to cool you down during the Caribbean’s extended summer

Jamaica and much of the Caribbean is sweating through what feels like an endless summer. Record-breaking heat and a noticeable delay in the usual...
Chef Wayne Sharpe

Miami Spice at Mangrove: Chef Wayne Sharpe showcases Jamaican flavors

Chef Wayne Sharpe's journey from a shy student at Tarrant High School in Kingston, Jamaica, to co-owner of Mangrove, Miami’s top-rated Caribbean restaurant in...
Worthy Park

Caribbean rums win big at 2025 International Wine and Spirit Competition

The Caribbean once again affirmed its reputation as the spiritual home of rum, as two standout Jamaican distilleries—Worthy Park Estate and Monymusk (National Rums...

Latest Articles