Isat Buchanan, a well-known attorney and figure in Jamaica, is no stranger to controversy. However, since being announced as the People’s National Party (PNP) candidate for East Portland in the upcoming general elections, slated for September 2025, his candidacy has ignited a fierce debate between Jamaica’s two major political parties: the governing Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) and the opposition PNP.
The JLP has expressed strong reservations about Buchanan’s nomination, citing his past criminal convictions for cocaine-related offenses both in Jamaica and the United States. They argue that these past indiscretions undermine the PNP’s moral authority on issues of corruption, crime, and ethics.
The PNP, however, has firmly stood by its choice of Buchanan, emphasizing its commitment to rehabilitation and redemption. They argue that his candidacy reflects a belief in second chances and the ability to contribute positively to society despite past mistakes.
The announcement of Buchanan’s candidacy has stirred significant political tension, particularly as it sets the stage for a potential showdown against the JLP’s Ann-Marie Vaz, who has served as the Member of Parliament for East Portland since 2019. The political clash has prompted bloggers and social media commentators to revive past allegations against both parties, intensifying the debate.
In their statements, the JLP highlighted Buchanan’s criminal history, including convictions for possession, dealing, and attempts to smuggle cocaine. While these convictions were reportedly expunged, the JLP pointed out that Buchanan served approximately 10 years in a U.S. prison for similar drug-related offenses.
“While we believe in possible rehabilitation and redemption, Mr. Buchanan’s recent crude, misogynistic, and lewd remarks directed at a senior female public servant and his description of some Jamaicans as ugly and resembling monkeys confirmed that his penchant for unbecoming conduct is not a thing of the past,” the JLP claimed.
In contrast, the PNP maintains that the JLP’s criticisms lack consistency, citing their own history of embracing candidates with criminal backgrounds. “Notably, a former JLP minister was re-elected after conviction, demonstrating that past transgressions have not prevented political success within their ranks,” the PNP stated.
The PNP believes Buchanan’s history does not define him but rather highlights his commitment to positive change. “Isat Buchanan’s candidacy is a reflection of the PNP’s commitment to rehabilitation and service. The people of East Portland deserve a representative who understands the value of redemption and can bring a fresh perspective to their community,” they declared.
Born on December 12, 1978, in Saint Andrew, Jamaica, Isat Aquaba Buchanan has shown remarkable resilience throughout his life. He is not only an Attorney-at-Law but also an artist, having attended Meadowbrook High School, the University of the West Indies, and the Norman Manley Law School, where he completed his law degree.
Growing up in a musical family—he is the son of renowned reggae icon Manley Augustus Buchanan, better known as Big Youth—Isat was deeply entrenched in the music scene. In 1990, he and his brother founded a rap group called “Thug Hype.” Despite his family’s extensive musical background, Buchanan initially aspired to become a gynecologist. However, destiny took him on a different path, leading him to become the attorney he is today.
As Buchanan prepares for the political arena, his candidacy continues to spark discussions about the role of personal history in politics and the capacity for change within individuals. With the election campaign heating up, the upcoming months will undoubtedly see more heated exchanges as both parties seek to assert their narratives ahead of the polls.
