ST. JOHN’S, Antigua – In a significant turn of events for regional cricket, Cricket West Indies (CWI) has officially withdrawn the four-match suspension previously imposed on John Campbell, captain of the Jamaica Scorpions, following a comprehensive review by its Code of Conduct and Disciplinary Tribunal held on Friday, April 4, 2025.
Though Campbell’s case was not directly on the Tribunal’s agenda, the hearing—originally convened to assess charges against Barbados Pride captain Raymon Reifer—ultimately raised broader concerns about the procedural fairness underpinning both cases. These developments led CWI to reassess its disciplinary actions and retract the penalty imposed on Campbell.
Flawed procedure, not faulty intent
The Tribunal was set to examine Reifer’s conduct during the CG United Super50 Final held on November 23, 2024. However, the panel determined that the manner in which charges were brought forward was procedurally flawed, rendering the case ineligible for formal hearing.
In a consequential ripple effect, the CWI recognized similar procedural issues in Campbell’s case, prompting the organization to withdraw the disciplinary charge, despite Campbell’s earlier admission of wrongdoing.
“We acknowledge the Tribunal’s observations and respect their role in ensuring procedural fairness,” stated Miles Bascombe, CWI Director of Cricket. “While Mr. Campbell’s expression of remorse and admission has been accepted, we recognize the concerns raised during Reifer’s hearing regarding the overall process and have decided to withdraw the suspension.”
Admission still stands, but process prevails
While Campbell’s apology and acceptance of responsibility remain on the record, CWI clarified that this decision was not based on the merit or innocence of the original charge, but solely on the procedural error in the charge’s submission.
“That said,” Bascombe emphasized, “this does not absolve individuals of responsibility where there have been serious breaches. No ruling has been made to declare a winner or overturn any match outcome—this is purely a matter of addressing procedural fairness. Neither has anyone been found guilty or innocent of charges.”
No resolution on prize money or match fees
While the disciplinary penalty against Campbell has been dropped, CWI confirmed that financial consequences tied to the disrupted Super50 Final remain in place. The withholding of prize money and match fees for both teams stands unresolved, as the Tribunal did not issue any ruling on that matter.
The final match, which did not take place under controversial circumstances, remains without a declared victor—a rare but telling moment in West Indies cricket that underscores the high standards of discipline and fairness upheld by CWI.
Consistency guides next steps for Reifer
In line with the findings of the Tribunal, CWI also confirmed that no further disciplinary proceedings will be pursued against Raymon Reifer at this stage, maintaining parity in its approach.
The independent disciplinary panel was chaired by Mr. Justice Patrick Thompson Jr and included a respected group of legal and cricketing minds: Mr. Justice Dale Staple, Mme. Justice Jacqueline Cornelius-Thorne, Mr. T. Michael Findlay, and Mr. Sylvester Joseph.
A defining moment for governance in West Indies cricket
This development signals a clear message from CWI: integrity is non-negotiable, but so too is due process. By accepting the Tribunal’s critique and correcting course, the organization demonstrates a balanced commitment to discipline, fairness, and procedural rigor.
As the regional cricketing fraternity reflects on this rare disciplinary reversal, the larger takeaway is clear—justice in sport is not only about outcomes, but about how those outcomes are reached.
 has officially withdrawn the four-match suspension previously imposed on John Campbell.){kind=link}